Fixed Annuity vs Variable Annuity: What’s the Difference?

TL;DR: Choosing the right type depends on individual financial goals, risk tolerance, and the need for either stable income or growth potential. Consulting a financial advisor is recommended.

• Fixed Annuity: Offers guaranteed returns and stable payouts, suitable for those prioritizing security.
• Variable Annuity: Provides potential for higher returns linked to market performance, but comes with greater risk.
• Main Differences:
  • Security: Fixed annuities offer more security with guaranteed payouts, whereas variable annuities involve market risk.
  • Return Potential: Variable annuities might yield higher returns compared to the generally lower returns of fixed annuities.
  • Complexity: Fixed annuities are simpler and easier to manage, while variable annuities require active management and understanding of various investment options.

---

The road to retirement is filled with many decisions. One of the most important is how to ensure a steady and reliable income stream throughout your golden years.

Enter annuities. These remain a popular retirement planning tool for their role in helping achieving financial security. However, the choice between a fixed annuity and a variable annuity can be complex, with each offering distinct advantages and challenges.

Fixed annuities provide the safety of guaranteed returns and a predictable payout schedule, making them an appealing choice for those who value stability over high returns. On the other hand, variable annuities offer the potential for higher returns linked to the performance of the underlying investments.

Understanding the nuances of a fixed annuity vs a variable annuity can help you tailor your retirement planning to your financial goals, risk tolerance, and long-term needs.

What is a Fixed Annuity?

Essentially, a fixed annuity provides a guaranteed return on your principal investment.

This type of annuity is commonly used as part of retirement planning since it offers a predictable stream of future income. Guaranteed interest rates are another perk. You can have peace of mind that your investment is safe against the volatility of the stock market.

Similarly, these earnings are tax-deferred. You only pay taxes when you withdraw money, which could help lower your tax burden during retirement.

How Fixed Annuities Work

1. Investment Phase: When you purchase a fixed annuity, you make a lump sum payment or a series of payments to the insurance company. In return, the company agrees to pay you a fixed rate of interest.
2. Accumulation Phase: The insurer invests your money (typically in low-risk fixed-income securities). Your investment grows at a predetermined interest rate, which is not affected by market fluctuations.
3. Payout Phase: Once the annuity matures, you can choose to receive payments in a lump sum or through regular disbursements, either for a certain period or for life. These payments include both the principal and interest.

What is a Variable Annuity?

A variable annuity offers the potential for higher returns but is more complex also comes with more risk. This is because it allows returns to fluctuate based on the performance of the investment options you choose.

Variable annuities provide a range of investment options. This can be attractive if you want to tailor your investments according to your risk tolerance and financial aspirations. However, keep in mind that returns are not guaranteed. There is the potential for loss, and these annuities typically include fees that can impact your returns.

How Variable Annuities Work

1. Investment Phase: Similar to fixed annuities, you make a lump sum payment or a series of payments. However, you can allocate these contributions among various investment options. This can include stocks, bonds, and money market funds.
2. Accumulation Phase: The value of your annuity changes based on the performance of your investment options. You can see significant growth if the markets perform well, but it also means more risk if the markets decline.
3. Payout Phase: You can choose to convert your annuity into periodic payments that may vary based on the value of your account. Some plans also offer a guaranteed minimum payout.

Fixed vs Variable Annuities: Key Differences

While both types of annuities can be used as part of retirement planning, it’s important to understand the differences between the two.

Here is a closer look at the fixed vs variable annuity pros and cons.

Pros and Cons of Fixed Annuities

Pros

• Security and Guaranteed Returns: Fixed annuities provide a stable, guaranteed income. This can be a cornerstone for a conservative retirement strategy.
• Predictability of Payouts: They offer the simplicity and comfort of knowing exactly how much income you will receive and when.
• Less Complexity and Easier to Understand: Fixed annuities are straightforward, making them easy for most investors to understand.

Cons

• Lower Return Potential: The safety of guaranteed returns comes at the cost of potentially lower gains.
• Inflation Risk: There is a risk that inflation could erode the purchasing power of your income over time.
• Limited Liquidity and Flexibility: Fixed annuities often come with significant surrender charges and limited options for early withdrawals.

Pros and Cons of Variable Annuities

Pros

• Higher Return Potential: Variable annuities can offer higher returns, especially in a strong market.
• Flexibility in Choosing Investment Options: Investors can diversify their holdings across different asset classes and adjust their portfolio according to their risk tolerance and market conditions.
• Potential for Increasing Income to Counteract Inflation: As investment returns rise, so too can payouts. This can help to maintain the purchasing power of retirement income.

Cons

• Higher Risk Due to Market Fluctuations: The potential for higher returns comes with increased risk. In other words, poor market performance can lead to lower retirement income.
• Complexity in Choices and Management: The variety of investment options requires more active management and a better understanding of securities. This can be daunting for some investors.
• Fees and Charges: Variable annuities can be expensive due to administrative fees, fund expenses, and mortality and expense charges, which can reduce the overall return.

Fixed Annuity vs Variable Annuity: Which is Best for You?

Choosing the right annuity for your retirement is a decision that requires balancing your financial goals with your risk tolerance. Of course, finding this balance is easier said than done.

Given the complexities and long-term implications of this choice, it’s crucial not to navigate these waters alone. Consulting with a financial advisor can provide you with tailored advice taking all these factors into account. They can help you understand the details of your investment options and guide you in making a choice that ensures you achieve a secure and rewarding retirement.

The right annuity is one that not only grows your savings but also gives you peace of mind in retirement. Let us craft a personalized financial plan designed to help you reach your goals.